Lubbock County is using its backup machine to count ballots after its main scanner developed problems. Former Elections Administrator Roxzine Stinson said the county needs a replacement before a full overhaul of its voting system, which County Judge Curtis Parrish favors doing in 2029.

Commissioners discussed the equipment at their Nov. 16 special meeting but did not approve either purchase or adopt a timetable. Parrish said he would target 2029 and replace the system all at once rather than in phases. One commissioner also favored waiting, citing interest rates. No financing plan was approved.

“My suggestion … is to put off any purchase like this until after the 2028 presidential general election,” Parrish said.

“We’re going to replace the whole thing.”

Curtis Parrish, Lubbock County judge

A scanner is needed sooner

Former Lubbock County Elections Administrator Roxzine Stinson said the county would need to replace its central ballot scanner before a full system overhaul because the elections office is already using its backup. Havard said the primary unit had problems and that Cranel, the company that services the central scanners, told the county it would not renew the maintenance agreement after summer 2027.

Elections Administrator Troy Havard recalled an earlier estimate of about $25,000 for one central scanner. He did not present a current stand-alone quote. He said the least expensive Hart InterCivic option replaces polling-place scanners, not the central scanners.

Havard said a purchase in 2027 could let the county use a new system before the presidential cycle. Otherwise, he suggested waiting until 2029.

“I have every confidence that it will serve us well,” Havard said of the existing system. “What I cannot promise is that we will not have a piece of equipment that may malfunction and need to be replaced.”

What a full replacement would cost

The three vendor quotes reviewed by Lubbock Lights ranged from $1,508,693.75 for the polling-place scanner upgrade to $8,985,550 for full replacement, plus $521,115 annually starting in year two. A third option was quoted at $7,171,500.

Havard said financing was available as an option but that he had not identified grant funding. Commissioners asked what discount, if any, Hart would offer for taking back the old equipment. No discount amount was established.

In a separate vote, commissioners approved the canvass of the Nov. 3 election results.